If hair metal was never popular...
Technically, hair/glam metal is more melodic/hard rock or pop-rock.
Bon Jovi? What about Def Leppard, which had a crossover with "Pryromania", Quiet Riot, Motley Crue, and to an extant Kiss & Van Halen, which many tend to take influence from.
Despite that glam/hair metal is now widely frowned upon by many, it had a wide appeal to the mainstream audience in the US. Also it appears that metal became more exposed by the media and certain watchdog groups with it's popularity.
While thrash was very much underground, especially the often kissed upon Metallica, I don't really know how popular metal was in the US in the early 1980's.
Granted that there was the PMRC, they also targeted Madonna & Prince (though Dee Snider of Twisted Sister testified along with Frank Zappa and John Denver).
Ironically enough, new wave also have been criticized for being more about "style over substance", though for some reason is more respected... I actually enjoy some new wave, but like all genres they have their share of the good and the bad...
Stewart from "Beavis & Butt-Head" would wear an Adam Ant shirt rather than Winger...
Honestly, I'm not sure. Though MTV gave exposure to alternative bands such as REM & Red Hot Chili Peppers towards the end of the decade.
sourceSubject: What if Hair Metal never took off in the 1980s?
In the mid 1980s, New Wave music was still around. Bands like Simple
Minds, Tears For Fears, and the Cars, were still making synth driven
music, that was representive of the New Wave sound. One of the big
hits in 1985, was the band A Ha's hit, "Take On Me", which was a very
new wave sound. Heavy Metal, while around, was more underground, and
confined to heavy metal fantics, and danky clubs, at least in my view.
Another name for the New Wave movement was the "New Romantics", which
were music bands that were about lush style, elegant lyrics, and synth
rock music. Duran Duran was one of the leaders of the New Romantics.
All of this came to an end, in 1986, with the release of the Bon Jovi
album, "Slippery When Wet". There was nothing breathtaking about this
album, it was a basic hard rock album with some pop touches. However,
it was a good album, that was very catchy, which is why it got on the
radio. With this album, according to what I have read, Heavy Metal
became mainstream, and respectable, rather then something that was
underground, and confined to stoners and clubs. Some would say, that
this was bad for heavy metal, because it ended up becoming about style
and looks, rather then intelligence and breaking new ground. Others
would say that since it made it more popular, that more people were
exposed to it, then if it was in it's former state. Others would say
that the hair bands, while some would seem to be stupid, they were
not all of the same. White Lion for example, while very much a Hair
Band, wrote some great songs like "If My Mind Is Evil", about
television preachers and Little Fighter, which was about a Greenpeace
ship.
My question is, what if mainstream Hair Metal never took off? Could
the New Wave, New Romantic music scene have survived into the 90s?
Could the Grunge, Alternative Rock movement have gone mainstream
sooner, because they would not have had the Hair Metal bands to
overcome first? What are your takes on this?